Barking Cat, Commerce AdvisoryBarking Cat Advisory Book a callBook

Every piece carries its date and at least one number. When a view changes, the old one stays up: the July Vendor Map sits beside October’s, with its two corrections listed.

Five of the pieces below come with a free tool: a budget builder, a KPI framework, stock intelligence, promotion economics and media efficiency. The Commercial Toolkit puts them in order.

November 2026

Index · Outerwear and Function

The Commercial Experience Index, Edition Three: Outerwear and Function

Twenty outerwear and function brands scored out of 100, read from the live UK shopfront on 17 November 2026. Arc’teryx top it on 72. The four highest-scoring sites never put a sign-up pop-up between the shopper and the product; fifteen of the other sixteen did. Full 24-page PDF free to download.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · The talk

The Barking Cat problem

Six assumptions every business case makes about the business, five about the customer, and ten questions to ask before approving the next investment. The full talk, with its transcript.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Why it never pays back

Why do our digital investments never quite pay back?

Six per cent of respondents can find AI in their profit. What the business case assumed about everyone else.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Incentives

Why do our people resist the investments we approve?

Every investment moves sales, credit, workload, budget or control between people, and the people who lose by it resist. How to price that before approval.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Measures

Why does the business report success the profit line does not show?

A campaign can report a ROAS of 3.14 and lose money on its last pound. When a measure becomes a target, it stops measuring. How to tell.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Alignment

Why does growth stall when every team is hitting its target?

Nine pairs of targets, each reasonable on its own, that pull against each other side by side. Misaligned objectives create friction, and friction blocks growth.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Decision rights

Why did our approved project never go live?

McKinsey put dynamic pricing at 5 to 10 percent more margin. The gain depends on every team between the model and the customer, and on settling their blocks before approval.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Capability

Does the business know how to run what it is buying?

Two kinds of knowledge an investment needs before the decision: how to do the new thing, and what the business already does. What to check.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Plumbing

Where did the saving in the business case go?

How a £3m business case fades to nothing visible in the P&L, and the three things to name before approval: the line, the owner and the baseline.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · The job

Should we cut the products that do not sell?

83% of 2,003 UK consumers say they discover products while browsing in store. Some products exist to sell others. How to tell before you cut.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · What we teach

What do our promotions teach customers to expect?

83% of 175 Black Friday products were the same price or cheaper at least once in the six months either side. What promotions teach, and what it costs.

November 2026

Barking Cat series · Three returns

Where does AI actually pay back for a retailer?

79.6% of retailers use AI for written content and 6.8% for dynamic pricing. The return sits mostly in the second.

November 2026

Article · AI investment

What most retailers need instead of a shopping agent

29% of AI shoppers say an AI tool shaped their last purchase most. Eight shopping agents tested on 10 November: none would place an order. What to build, and what not to.

November 2026

Article · Replatforming

Should we pay less for development now AI writes the code?

AI models given no security guidance still introduced a vulnerability in 38% of Veracode’s coding tasks. What that should change in what you ask of your agency.

October 2026

Tool · Margin and promotions

Contribution and Media Efficiency

A ROAS of 5.7 that returns £1.03 per pound once margin, returns and incrementality come off. Contribution per campaign, the return on the last pound, a step-down test and a verdict for each. Free workbook, no form.

October 2026

Tool · Margin and promotions

Promotion Economics

Every function claims the uplift. At 25% off a 50% margin line, volume has to double to stand still; the workbook says so before the event and gives a verdict after it. Free workbook, no form.

October 2026

Tool · Trading and KPIs

Availability and Stock Intelligence

Seven broken size curves and £465k of markdown exposure, found in one weekly export. Availability, weeks cover and sell-through at size level, ranked by the money at stake. Free workbook, no form.

October 2026

Tool · Trading and KPIs

The Ecommerce KPI Framework

49 KPIs classed as decision, trigger, context or misleading. Two of the misleading five will start an argument: conversion across all sessions, and ROAS. Free workbook, no form.

October 2026

Tool · Trading and KPIs

The Ecommerce Budget Builder

A weekly budget built from three years of trading history. In the sample, £500,000 of extra media buys £1.29m of sales and £32,000 of contribution. Free workbook, no form.

October 2026

Kit · On the day

How to Trade the Golden Quarter

For the event days themselves. One peak morning read: sales up 6%, orders up 46%, average order value down 27%. The kit is built to catch that. Free PDF, no form.

October 2026

Map · AI investment

The Retail AI Vendor Map, October 2026

The three layers re-verified to 1 October. Salesforce closed on Fin, the model frontier began shipping to restricted groups first, and in September US checkout moved back inside the assistant by platform default. What changed since July is listed at the foot of the page.

October 2026

Article · AI investment

The chatbot paradox

Conversational AI earns its keep where the customer cannot choose alone, and very little where they can. IMRG’s 0.39%, a peer-reviewed study of 973 websites, and a first-hand test of an AI stylist with nothing to style.

October 2026

Article · AI investment

Which retailers do AI shopping agents put at risk?

An AI stylist placed inside ChatGPT sent me to another retailer within three minutes. What agents compare, who they leave exposed, and the clause ASOS’s principle needs next.

October 2026

Article · AI investment

Adoption is an operating-model question

37% of organisations see any EBIT impact from AI, unchanged in a year. Ownership, failover and funding decide the rest, and ecommerce taught the same lesson a decade earlier.

October 2026

Talk · Customer experience

What customers say and what they do

In 2017, 300 of 400 store managers stood up to say ecommerce was stealing their sales. The eCommerce Expo session, written up: five kinds of customer signal and a test before any of them earns a decision.

September 2026

Playbook · Before peak

Bulletproof for the Golden Quarter

The Q4 readiness playbook: seven foundations where a binding constraint can hide, the 2025 peak read through Currys and The Works, and a 23-point pre-peak checklist. Free, no form.

September 2026

Article · Replatforming

Should we replatform?

Six questions a retail board should ask before a £3m replatform, from an operator who has led eight, and the four functions one programme forgot to ask.

August 2026

Index · Premier League club shops

The Commercial Experience Index, Edition Two: Premier League Club Shops

All twenty Premier League club online stores, scored out of 100 across eight measures read from the live shopfront. Bournemouth top the table on 73. The famous clubs build good stores for humans and poor ones for machines, and sixteen of the twenty return a 404 where an AI agent looks first. Full 26-page PDF free to download.

August 2026

Article · AI investment

The two numbers the AI visibility industry keeps confusing

The industry is awash with AI statistics, most quoted with more confidence than they have earned. I have read the studies so you do not have to. Two conversion figures, roughly 15 percent and roughly 2 percent, are being confused for one another, and the message underneath the noise is calm: AI has not remade ecommerce yet.

August 2026

Index · Ten UK retail sites

The Commercial Experience Index, Edition One

Ten UK retail sites scored out of 100. Finisterre and Passenger top it; SKIMS posts the worst single mobile metric in the review. PDF available.

2016, republished July 2026

Article · Replatforming

The Five-Stage Retail Transformation Model

The journey mapped for UK retailers in 2016, naming AI personalisation as the destination a decade early. Republished as written, with a note on what held.

July 2026

Map · AI investment

The Retail AI Vendor Map, July 2026

Three layers, category judgements, and the sequencing questions that come before any vendor conversation.

Contact

Name the decision in front of the business and the date it has to be made.

If there is work in it, a fixed fee, in writing, within two working days.

Connect on LinkedIn

BOOK A CALL